communityfix.org

Case study of

#00142 Embed photovoltaics directly into the running surface of roads and paths

Krommenie, North Holland, Netherlands

#00142

PartialNeighborhood

Implementer

SolaRoad consortium (TNO, Province of North Holland, and partners)

Timeline

Oct 21, 2014 – Jun 1, 2019

Location

Krommenie, North Holland, Netherlands52.4939, 4.7681

Description

SolaRoad opened a 72 m solar cycle path in Krommenie in October 2014 (later extended to ~90 m), operated by the SolaRoad consortium (TNO, Province of North Holland, and partners). Because the load was limited to cyclists, the path survived better than road-embedded PV pilots and generated ~9,800 kWh in its first year (~3 households). However, the protective top coating cracked and required early replacement, output per m² was roughly half that of conventional rooftop systems a few kilometres away, and installed cost was ~US$1,000–1,400/m², implying a payback of many decades. A 'bad road surface' warning was posted in January 2020 and the path was ultimately removed. The case demonstrates that reducing axle load improves durability but does not close the orientation penalty or cost gap versus rooftop PV.

Metrics

3
First-year energy output~9,800kWh/yr
Yield per m² vs nearby rooftop PVrooftop = 1×~0.5×relative
Installed cost per m²~1,000–1,400USD/m²

Funding

Province of North Holland and consortium partners

Lessons learned

  • Even the most favourable surface-embedded case — a light-traffic bike path — produced about half the per-m² yield of ordinary rooftop solar due to flat orientation, not load.
  • Reducing the load (bikes not trucks) fixes durability enough to keep it running but does not address the fundamental cost gap versus rooftop panels.
  • A protective top layer durable enough for outdoor path use still cracked and needed early replacement, adding lifecycle cost beyond initial installation.
  • The relevant benchmark is not 'does it generate electricity' but 'does it outperform the same panels mounted on a nearby roof' — this pilot did not.

Documented Jul 13, 2026

Author AvatarArnaud Gissinger

History

· 1
Createdapproved

Arnaud Gissinger · 5h ago · approved by Arnaud Gissinger 5h ago


communityfix.org